facebook rss twitter

Microsoft says hybrid graphics make for a poor user experience

by Parm Mann on 7 November 2008, 11:09

Tags: Microsoft (NASDAQ:MSFT), ATi Technologies (NYSE:AMD), NVIDIA (NASDAQ:NVDA)

Quick Link: HEXUS.net/qap34

Add to My Vault: x

Various manufacturers seem to think that squeezing more GPUs into desktop or notebook systems is the way to attract the enthusiast market. Microsoft, however, believes that two-or-more GPUs just ain't all that.

At WinHec 2008 in Los Angeles, Microsoft made available a document entitled Guidelines for Graphics in Windows 7 and there's one particular section that'll bring frowns to the faces of both NVIDIA and AMD.

According to the document, Microsoft's forthcoming Windows 7 operating system won't offer native support for hybrid graphics. Furthermore, the software giant will be advising system manufacturers to avoid utilising such technology, stating that it results in an unstable system that provides a poor user experience. The relevant section reads:


"A hybrid graphics system typically has two GPUs: a low-power, fairly low-performance integrated GPU and a second high-power, higher performance discrete GPU.

The integrated GPU is typically used when long battery life is desired, and the discrete GPU is used when battery life is not important or when higher performance is required. Such systems require a reboot to switch between GPUs.

Windows 7 does not offer native support for hybrid graphics systems. We strongly discourage system manufacturers from shipping such systems, which can be unstable and provide a poor user experience."


It's becoming increasingly common for notebooks to feature an IGP and discrete GPU combination, but it's a trend that Microsoft is hoping to change, and it may have a point. At present, a notebook equipped with an IGP and a dedicated GPU has the advantage of switching between the two to save battery life. However, it could be argued that the savings don't warrant the use of complex technology that results in larger and more expensive systems.

Despite NVIDIA and AMD pushing multi-GPUs as the best thing in graphics, a HEXUS poll earlier this year found that SLI and CrossFire configurations remain a niche solution with very few readers showing any intent to use multi-GPU technology in the near future.

Microsoft, it seems, believes that better-optimised single-GPU solutions that are capable of throttling performance on-the-fly as required, are the way forward. Opportunity knocks for Intel's Larrabee, perhaps.



HEXUS Forums :: 16 Comments

Login with Forum Account

Don't have an account? Register today!
Seems odd although I suspect they have their reasons.

Anyone here running hybrid graphics and having issues?
i havnt been able to get a 780g hd 3450 hybrid system running well at all with Vista 32. There is hardly any documentation and most help suggestions are “reinstall windows”
The hybrid graphics on a laptop is a good idea, 1 for games, 1 for 2d/battery life. But as Hexus say - just doing the scaling right with one graphics card is a much better solution.

It's a bit worrying Microsoft bringing back the ‘Please reboot your computer’ though…
Microsoft says hybrid graphics make for a poor user experience
And users say Windows makes for a head smashing experience.

Id like to hear nVidia's and AMD's response to this, considering its the path they chose to make them some money.
seems a bit of a strange move since around 2 weeks ago apple released macbook's with hybrid graphics from Nvidia.
if you need a reboot to switch between the GPU's its eiether poorly written drivers or the way the operating system works. im sure microsoft could sort it out so you dont need a reboot to switch between modes. then again if all graphics cards used less power when they werent needed that would be a much better solution.