facebook rss twitter

W3C exec urges delay in HTML5 deployment

by Pete Mason on 7 October 2010, 14:28

Quick Link: HEXUS.net/qa2ge

Add to My Vault: x

Some - mildly influential - individuals would have you believe that HTML5 is the future of the web and the obvious successor to Adobe Flash. However, an executive from W3C - the body which oversees the standard - has expressed concern over some companies' willingness to adopt the format.

Philippe Le Hegaret, the World Wide Web Consortium's Interaction Domain Leader, explained (courtesy of InfoWorld) that "it's a little too early to deploy [HTML5] because we're running into interoperability issues". He added that the standard was not yet ready for production, largely because the consortium still had plans to amend the underlying APIs.

He concluded that "the real problem is can we make [HTML5] work across browsers and at the moment, that is not the case."

Google has recently been experimenting with HTML5 in its doodles

Of course, Le Hegaret's comments make sense. Though the latest versions of Firefox, Opera, Webkit-based browsers such as Chrome and Safari and the beta of Internet Explorer 9 can all handle HTML5, public adoption is not nearly as wide. Even as it continues to lose market-share, older versions of IE still account for a very large chunk of the browser market, while legacy releases of some other browsers also remain prevalent.

Final approval of the standard is expected to occur in three to four years time, though it will be 'feature-complete' by the middle of next year.

HTML5 is generating a huge amount of interest among the big-hitters of the tech-industry, from Apple to Google, Mozilla and more.  However, until it is accessible to a very large proportion of the web-browsing population and the interoperability issues have been worked out, wide-scale adoption is likely to cause more problems than it solves.



HEXUS Forums :: 3 Comments

Login with Forum Account

Don't have an account? Register today!
I can understand them delaying it if they need to make changes to it, but if it is just old browsers that is stopping it I say go ahead, might finally get all those slackers with old browsers to upgrade
I agree with Flash477, anything that can be done to encourage people/companies to upgrade to more modern and securer web browsers is surely a good thing. Why should the rest of the web community be held back because some do not want to upgrade from ie6?

PS I realise that some companies will find it differcult to move from ie6 as their infrastructure may rely on specific software written for ie6 (or other version).
Flash477
I can understand them delaying it if they need to make changes to it, but if it is just old browsers that is stopping it I say go ahead, might finally get all those slackers with old browsers to upgrade
No, the problem is, if companies start deploying HTML5 browsers and pages *now*, that'll mean the draft HTML5 standard will be prematurely entrenched before it's ready for consumption and will be fragmented and highly resistant to change like what happened to IEEE802.11n.