facebook rss twitter

MSI Radeon HD 5870 Lightning graphics card review. One of a kind?

by Tarinder Sandhu on 15 March 2010, 23:44

Tags: MSI Radeon HD 5870 Lightning (10.2), MSI

Quick Link: HEXUS.net/qawkc

Add to My Vault: x

Final thoughts and rating

MSI set out to create the finest Radeon HD 5870 graphics card that money can buy. Based on the fastest single-GPU gaming card at the time of writing, MSI has thrown everything, including the kitchen sink, at the R5870 Lightning.

Starting off with a fully-custom PCB, 15-phase PWM, voltage-monitoring points and twin 80mm fans on top of a large heatsink, the basic ingredients are good. The R5870 Lightning ships with a 900MHz core - 50MHz up from stock - and default-clocked memory, but chances are that the enthusiast will overclock it farther.

Drilling down, the extra components push the power-draw of the card up by 40W when compared with a generic HD 5870. In doing so, the Twin FrozrII cooler has to work harder at keeping the GPU at <80°C, which means it becomes noisy under load as the fans spin up to almost 4,000rpm.

Increase the voltage to 1.25V via the supplied Afterburner utility and the card overclocks to 960MHz core and 5,000MHz memory- the memory speed being shy of what we're used to. The Lightning, which has better-than-average cooling, shows that there really isn't much headroom in the Radeon HD 5870 GPU.

Radeon HD 5870 is a good GPU and MSI benefits from producing a card on a class-leading architecture. But has the company achieved the aim of best HD 5870? Not quite, we feel, as the noisy fans and modest memory overclock are bettered by cheaper custom-designed cards.

£360 is a lot of money to spend in a single graphics card, and whilst MSI's R5870 Lightning really does look the business, there's better value elsewhere.

The good

Lots of thought has gone into the custom design
Core clock of 900MHz is one of the highest we've seen for a Radeon HD 5870

The not so good

Twin fans spin up at a noisy 4,000rpm under load
Stock memory frequency and poor overclocked potential
Doesn't offer a significant increase in performance over a reference card that's £50 cheaper

HEXUS Rating



MSI R5870 Lightning at £360


HEXUS Where2Buy

The MSI R5870 Lightning graphics card can be ordered from the following retailers:


As always, UK-based HEXUS.community discussion forum members will benefit from the SCAN2HEXUS Free Shipping initiative, which will save you a further few pounds plus also top-notch, priority customer service and technical support backed up by the SCANcare@HEXUS forum.

TBC
 
TBC
TBC

HEXUS Right2Reply

At HEXUS, we invite the companies whose products we test to comment on our articles. If any company representatives for the products reviewed choose to respond, we'll publish their commentary here verbatim.



HEXUS Forums :: 9 Comments

Login with Forum Account

Don't have an account? Register today!
Can we start having Bad Company 2 in the benchmarks (maybe use the Jeep part from the first level?), also I think the lightest of the green bars is too light!
From power draw & temperatures
“the Sapphire HD 5870 Vapor-X (870MHz/5,200MHz clocks) draws a system-wide 316W and the cooler is able to keep the GPU to 64°C”

This card isn't in the tabled comparisons? It would have been nice to see it compared fully as it was referenced here. Otherwise better to reference cards that are in the tables maybe?
rabbid
From power draw & temperatures
“the Sapphire HD 5870 Vapor-X (870MHz/5,200MHz clocks) draws a system-wide 316W and the cooler is able to keep the GPU to 64°C”

This card isn't in the tabled comparisons? It would have been nice to see it compared fully as it was referenced here. Otherwise better to reference cards that are in the tables maybe?

I appreciate your thinking here, but that card was tested on drivers which were three revisions old and may have skewed results in its favour. The temperatures and load readings, however, were undertaken with the same ambient conditions.

It was included more as a cooler comparison than anything else.
Terbinator
I think the lightest of the green bars is too light!
Will fix that. Are the graphs better though?
Steve
Will fix that. Are the graphs better though?

Yeah, saves me having to reference the legend every time I look at a single bar xD :rockon2: